If Walls Could Talk- Grisly Deeds in the Ladies Comfort Station

Sometime just before 11:15 a.m. on Thursday, August 11, 1892, the two bodies of Abby and Andrew Borden, deceased for a week, were removed from the hillside holding tomb where they had been shelved since August 6th- the day of their funeral at Oak Grove Cemetery. Holding tombs were required to receive the coffins during the winter months in New England when the ground was too hard to dig a grave. This particular tomb has shelving on both sides and is built into a hill where the cool earth helps to preserve the body. Today this tomb holds only lawnmowers.

Entering through the great arch on Prospect Street, the little building to the left inside the gate is the ladies comfort station, to the right is the office and the gentlemen’s comfort station. Today the office remains but the ladies comfort station is a break room for the cemetery workmen.

The post card from 1907 shows the comfort station on the left. Straight ahead in the center of the arch is the Civil War obelisk given by Col. Richard Borden in memory and honor of the fallen Union soldiers buried all together there.. Today the ivy has been cleaned off the arch which says “The Shadows Have Fallen and They Wait for the Day”.

Shortly before 11:15, Medical Examiner W. A. Dolan, assisted by Boston ‘s Dr. F.W. Draper, Dr. John H. Leary of Fall River, and Dr. Dwight Cone , city physician, entered the ladies comfort station to perform a second autopsy and to remove the heads of Andrew and Abby Borden.

One can only imagine the proceedings within these walls, and the faces of the men as they exited this door, two unseemly bundles in hand. The little building is of granite stone blocks, and is divided into two inner chambers. On the left is the tiled lavatory with conveniences for the ladies and a sink. The tiles are still there, including some ornamental tiles at the top of the wainscotting which feature a Greek key motif. The room on the right still has the dark wood panel wainscotting and wide window and door moldings. The beautiful stained glass windows were vandalized long ago but shards of lavender and nile green glass jut from the lancet frames behind the boarded up openings. This is the room where the grisly deeds were done, and the room from which the sad, headless corpses of Abby and Andrew were taken to be laid forever headless in the damp earth. The heads were eventually buried after the trial, in separate small boxes over the top of the coffins. The workmen today know this story and sometimes look uneasily around their “break room” when the story is mentioned. After all of this, the good doctors washed their hands in the lavatory, and went home to their lunch.